Secure peace of mind knowing that your institution's art assets are properly protected
Identify, Evaluate, and Insure Your Institution's Art Assets Effectively
Many colleges and universities house valuable fine art collections in prominent locations like museums and galleries, and scattered across offices, departments, and within architecturally significant campus buildings. While these assets contribute to campus culture and academic life, they also pose potential risks if not properly managed. Ensuring that these collections are adequately insured requires a clear understanding of their locations and values and designing an appropriate risk mitigation strategy for each piece.
Below is a detailed, step-by-step approach that may help risk managers to identify, evaluate, and insure their institution’s art assets effectively, ultimately helping to safeguard these cultural and financial treasures.
The Importance of Campus Art Risk Management
Imagine walking across campus and noticing a newly installed sculpture on loan from a generous donor, along with a colorful poster announcing a rare print exhibit. Does this sound familiar? Now, picture a cracked stained-glass window or a water-damaged collection in the basement after a pipe burst. Both scenarios involve risk and highlight the need for proactive risk management. Without proper planning, valuable artworks remain vulnerable. Similarly, without adequate coverage, the institution itself remains at risk. A specialty fine art insurance broker may serve as a helpful guide to assist you in navigating issues related to, and outside of, a specialty fine art insurance policy.
The goal of this article is to help you establish a systematic process that provides peace of mind—knowing that, in the event of damage or loss, your institution is prepared with appropriate coverage and risk controls.
Step 1: Identify the Property to be Insured
The first step is to determine exactly which artworks and objects need coverage. Fine art insurance policies typically offer broad coverage, including:
- Works of art, sculptures, rare books, documents, artifacts, and musical instruments
- Collections of historical, scientific, or archaeological importance
- Technical equipment, such as scientific instruments and equipment used in exhibitions, such as monitors and projectors
- Registration papers, provenance records, and documentation
Understanding what is covered may help prevent gaps in protection and ensure that all valuable assets are accounted for properly.
Step 2: Locate and Inventory All Art Collections
Next, you need to identify where all campus artworks are stored or displayed. While obvious locations like art museums and library special collections are straightforward to find, many pieces may be housed in less obvious departments or storage areas.
Conducting a campus-wide survey is essential. Engage department heads to provide detailed information about their collections, including:
- Descriptions of each piece (artist, title, year, medium, dimensions), especially if full lists are available; for extensive lists, focus on the top 10 or 20 items
- Exact location (building, room, storage facility)
- Estimated value (both total and for the most valuable objects)
- Security measures and environmental controls, including facility reports, if available
- Loan status and borrowing details, with lists of short-term and long-term loaned objects for top-valued items
Maintaining accurate, up-to-date inventories is critical. These records should be reviewed periodically—at least annually—to account for new acquisitions, deaccessions, or relocations.
Why This Is Important
Insurance underwriters expect institutions to maintain detailed records of their high-value collections. While a complete inventory of every item may not always be practical, focusing on the most valuable pieces helps ensure adequate coverage and makes claims processing easier if needed.
Step 3: Understand Contractual Responsibilities for Borrowed Art
Many institutions borrow artworks for exhibitions or research. These loans involve contractual agreements that specify responsibilities, including insurance coverage. It’s important to review each loan agreement carefully to ensure that the agreed-upon value matches your insurance policy. A formal loan agreement should clearly specify the lender and borrower, the loan period, the condition of the artwork, insurance responsibilities, and liability clauses. We recommend verifying that these contracts align with your insurance coverage to prevent gaps in protection.
Long-term loans should be reviewed periodically and updated to reflect current market values. Proper documentation, including signed loan agreements and detailed inventories, helps prevent disputes and ensures that both parties are protected.
Key considerations include:
- The insured value of borrowed items
- Responsibilities for damage or loss during transit and display
- Conditions for returning the artwork
- Any unique requirements or provisions
Step 4: Assess the Value of Your Art Collections
While curators and art historians often focus on cultural and aesthetic significance, understanding the financial value is equally important for insurance purposes. Knowing the approximate market value of collections helps risk managers set appropriate coverage limits. There are pricing tools available that are not formal appraisals, but can provide basic information, which may help assess risk exposure.
Obtaining professional appraisals is generally the most reliable method. Qualified appraisers can visually inspect and determine:
- Retail replacement value (the cost to replace the artwork today)
- Fair market value (the current market worth)
- Value for insurance, donation, or deaccession purposes
If a full appraisal isn’t feasible due to budget constraints, institutions may wish to explore resources such tech-based pricing tools, student-engaged projects, or grants dedicated to conservation and appraisal efforts. Regularly updated appraisals and valuation projects help ensure that coverage remains aligned with current values, especially as art market prices fluctuate.
Choosing an appraiser: Select professionals certified by reputable organizations such as the Appraisers Association of America, the American Society of Appraisers, or the International Society of Appraisers. Make sure they have expertise in the specific type of art or artifacts you possess.
Step 5: Evaluate Probable Maximum Loss and Implement Risk Controls
Understanding the worst-case scenario—known as the probable maximum loss (PML)—is important for effective risk management. PML estimates the largest potential loss from natural disasters, accidents, theft, or vandalism, if active safety systems function properly.
Assessing PML involves considering factors such as:
- Building construction and fire resistance
- Fire detection and suppression systems (sprinklers, alarms)
- Security measures (cameras, access controls)
- Environmental controls (temperature, humidity)
- External risks (flood zones, earthquake-prone areas)
Once PML is estimated, develop risk control measures to reduce these risks. These include:
- Installing or upgrading fire suppression and security systems
- Creating emergency response and disaster recovery plans
- Training staff on handling and protecting artworks
- Regularly inspecting and maintaining environmental controls
An annual review of these measures helps ensure ongoing protection and preparedness.
Step 6: Develop and Maintain Risk Control Measures
Effective risk management requires a comprehensive approach that covers physical security, environmental safety, staff training, and emergency preparedness. Create checklists tailored to your campus’s specific risks, including:
- Location hazards (flood plains, earthquake zones)
- Staff recruitment, training, and supervision
- Building construction, fire safety, and security systems
- Environmental controls (HVAC, humidity, light)
- IT security for digital records and backups
- Policies for handling, storage, and transportation of artworks
- Emergency response plans and coordination with local authorities
If your campus has a museum, consider engaging them to understand their standards of practice. Conduct these reviews annually, especially when renovations, construction projects, or new collections are involved.
Step 7: Procure the Right Fine Art Insurance Coverage
With your inventories, appraisals, and risk controls in place, the next step is to secure appropriate insurance coverage. Specialized fine arts policies offer several advantages over standard property insurance:
- Broader coverage, including accidental damage, theft, and mysterious disappearance
- Worldwide protection, covering artworks in transit, on loan, or stored off-site
- Flexible valuation options, such as “current market value” or “agreed insurance value”
- Lower deductibles, often zero for in-transit or loaned works
- Automatic coverage, for newly acquired items and ongoing loans
It’s advisable to work with an insurance broker experienced in representing institutions or cultural collections. They may help tailor a policy that aligns with your institution’s specific needs, including coverage for special collections, artist-in-residence programs, and artwork by students or faculty.
What to provide when requesting a quote:
- Schedule of insurance, including COPE data and basic security details
- Total estimated value of collections, broken down by location and department
- Detailed inventories, highlighting high-value items
- Exhibition schedule, if applicable
- Past loss history and claims data
- Information on outdoor sculptures and any off-campus storage
Protecting Your Campus Art Assets
Investing time and resources into identifying, valuing, and insuring campus art collections is important for safeguarding these cultural assets. While the process may be complex, a systematic approach—including thorough inventories, professional appraisals, risk assessments, and specialized insurance—helps ensure that your institution is prepared for any situation.
In moments of crisis, such as water damage or theft, knowing that your collections are properly insured may provide peace of mind. Ultimately, proactive risk management not only helps preserve the integrity of your campus’s artistic heritage but also reflects responsible stewardship of valuable assets.
By Anne Rappa, Senior Vice President and U.S. Fine Art Practice Leader | Marsh and McLennan Agency
Insights Home
#InsightsArticle